Skip to content

Nucleic acid extraction methods compared: spin column, magnetic bead, CTAB and phenol-chloroform

Every extraction does the same four things: lyse, separate, wash, elute. The chemistry you use for each step decides yield, purity and how many samples you can run a day.

Range: Nucleic acid extraction and purification4 minute readUpdated

Researcher loading samples into a benchtop centrifuge
On this page
  1. Key points
  2. The four steps every method shares
  3. Silica spin columns
  4. Magnetic beads
  5. CTAB extraction for plants
  6. Phenol-chloroform and TRIzol-type extraction
  7. Methods compared
  8. Checking the result
  9. Questions

Key points

  • Every extraction lyses the sample, separates nucleic acid from everything else, washes it and elutes or redissolves it.
  • Silica spin columns are the everyday choice: fast, clean and safe for small batches. Magnetic beads scale to plates and automation.
  • CTAB extraction handles plant tissue rich in polysaccharides and polyphenols; phenol-chloroform gives high yield but uses hazardous solvents.
  • Judge the result by A260/280, A260/230 and integrity, not by yield alone.

The four steps every method shares

  1. Lysis breaks cells and nuclei open with detergents, chaotropic salts, enzymes such as proteinase K, or mechanical bead beating.
  2. Separation parts nucleic acid from proteins, lipids and debris, by binding to silica, partitioning into a solvent phase or precipitation.
  3. Washing removes salts, proteins and other contaminants that would inhibit enzymes downstream.
  4. Elution or resuspension releases clean DNA or RNA into a low-salt buffer or water.

Silica spin columns

In the presence of chaotropic salts such as guanidine and ethanol, DNA and RNA bind to a silica membrane while proteins and other contaminants pass through. Ethanol washes remove the rest, and a low-salt buffer, typically 10 mM Tris at pH 8 to 8.5, releases the nucleic acid.

Columns are quick, need only a microcentrifuge and give reproducible purity, which makes them the format of most extraction kits. Their limits are throughput and the membrane’s binding capacity.

Magnetic beads

Paramagnetic particles coated with silica or carboxyl groups bind nucleic acid in the same way, but are collected with a magnet instead of a centrifuge. Without spins, beads handle 96 samples at once on a magnetic stand or a liquid-handling robot, and the protocol scales to different input volumes. They are the standard for high-throughput and automated extraction.

CTAB extraction for plants

Plant tissue is full of polysaccharides and polyphenols that co-purify with DNA and inhibit PCR. The cationic detergent CTAB (cetyltrimethylammonium bromide) forms complexes that separate them from DNA at high salt.

CTAB extraction buffer (final concentrations)
ComponentConcentrationRole
CTAB2% (w/v)Lyses membranes; separates polysaccharides
Tris-HCl, pH 8.0100 mMBuffer
EDTA20 mMChelates Mg²⁺ to inhibit nucleases
NaCl1.4 MHigh salt keeps polysaccharides out of the DNA fraction
PVP1–2% (optional)Binds polyphenols
β-mercaptoethanol0.2%, added just before usePrevents polyphenol oxidation
  1. Grind tissue to a fine powder in liquid nitrogen.
  2. Add pre-warmed CTAB buffer and incubate at 60–65 °C for 30–60 minutes, mixing occasionally.
  3. Extract with an equal volume of chloroform:isoamyl alcohol (24:1) and centrifuge.
  4. Precipitate DNA from the aqueous phase with 0.7 volumes of isopropanol.
  5. Wash the pellet with 70% ethanol, air-dry briefly and dissolve in TE buffer.

Phenol-chloroform and TRIzol-type extraction

Organic extraction partitions proteins into a phenol phase and leaves nucleic acids in the aqueous phase, followed by alcohol precipitation. Acid guanidinium thiocyanate-phenol reagents (TRIzol-type) do the same for RNA while inactivating RNases. These methods give high yields from many sample types, but they are slow, hard to scale and use toxic solvents. Most labs now reserve them for samples that columns handle poorly.

Methods compared

Nucleic acid extraction methods
MethodSpeedThroughputPurityHazardsBest for
Spin columnFastLow to mediumHighLowMost routine extractions
Magnetic beadsFastHigh, automatableHighLow96-well and automated workflows
CTABSlowLowGood for plantsChloroform, β-MEPolysaccharide-rich plant tissue
Phenol-chloroformSlowLowGood with carePhenol, chloroformHigh yield from difficult samples
Salting outMediumLow to mediumModerateLowGenomic DNA from blood

Checking the result

  • A260/280: about 1.8 for DNA and 2.0 for RNA. Lower values point to protein or phenol.
  • A260/230: ideally 2.0–2.2. Lower values point to guanidine salts, polysaccharides or phenol.
  • Integrity: a tight high molecular weight band for DNA; intact ribosomal RNA bands or an integrity score for RNA.
  • Quantity: fluorometric dyes measure DNA or RNA specifically, where absorbance counts everything that absorbs at 260 nm.

Different samples bring different contaminants. The extraction by sample type guide covers blood, tissue, plant, stool, viral samples and plasmids one by one, and the PCR vs qPCR guide covers what happens next.

Questions we get asked

What is the best nucleic acid extraction method?

For most samples, a silica spin-column kit gives the best balance of speed, purity and safety. Magnetic beads are better for high throughput and automation. CTAB suits plant tissue rich in polysaccharides, and organic extraction suits difficult samples where yield matters most.

What is CTAB extraction buffer used for?

It is used to extract DNA from plant tissue. The detergent CTAB lyses cells and, at high salt, separates DNA from the polysaccharides and polyphenols that plants contain, which would otherwise inhibit PCR.

Spin column or magnetic beads?

Spin columns suit a few to a few dozen samples with simple equipment. Magnetic beads suit 96-well plates and automation, and adapt more easily to different sample volumes.

Why is my DNA yield low?

Common causes are incomplete lysis, too much starting material overloading the column, ethanol left on the membrane before elution, or eluting in too small a volume. Pre-warming the elution buffer and a second elution can also help.

Sources

  1. Rapid and simple method for purification of nucleic acids. Boom R et al. J Clin Microbiol. 1990;28:495-503.
  2. Single-step method of RNA isolation by acid guanidinium thiocyanate-phenol-chloroform extraction. Chomczynski P et al. Anal Biochem. 1987;162:156-9.
  3. Rapid isolation of high molecular weight plant DNA. Murray MG et al. Nucleic Acids Res. 1980;8:4321-5.

For research use only. Protocols here are general outlines: follow your kit manual and your institution’s safety rules. See our editorial policy.

Products for this workflow

Nucleic acid extraction and purification

DNA, RNA and plasmid kits, with sample-specific kits for blood, tissue, plant, fecal and viral RNA samples.

Need the reagents for this?

Send the product names or catalogue numbers, quantities and delivery country. We'll confirm availability, lead time and the documents for nucleic acid extraction and purification.